A dramatic turn has unfolded in the ongoing legal battle between Apple and Epic Games, with a judge delivering an unusually harsh rebuke to Tim Cook’s company.
What began as a potential slap on the wrist has escalated into a significant blow for Apple. The tech giant has been accused of abusing its monopolistic power, failing to adhere to previous agreements, and now potentially faces a criminal investigation. Let’s break down the key developments.
Since 2020, Apple and Epic Games – renowned for titles like Fortnite and Unreal, its Unreal Engine technology, and the Epic Games Store – have been locked in a dispute. Epic sought to bypass Apple’s standard 30% commission on in-app transactions by offering its own payment system within the iOS environment, thus circumventing Apple’s mandatory purchase pathway.
Unsurprisingly, Apple retaliated by removing Epic’s games, including the immensely popular Fortnite, from the App Store. Consequently, iPhone users were temporarily unable to play it (and still cannot in the US). Epic subsequently filed an antitrust lawsuit against Apple, alleging monopolistic practices. While Epic didn’t achieve a complete victory initially, a significant change did occur.
In 2021, the court ruled that Apple could not prevent third-party apps from offering alternative payment methods outside of its own system. However, Apple’s response was perceived by many as a circumvention of this ruling. While they technically allowed alternative payments, they actively discouraged users from utilizing them and imposed a substantial 27% commission on such transactions – a move with the potential to generate billions of dollars annually. This very action by Apple lies at the heart of the current controversy.
Epic successfully convinced the court that Apple was not complying with the 2021 verdict. California Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers (who has also overseen legal battles involving Elon Musk) has now mandated that Apple eliminate the 27% fee. “This is not a negotiation. This is a court order,” she stated firmly. “When you knowingly disregard a court order, you don’t get a second chance.”
The imposed fee, maintained by Apple in defiance of the prior ruling, was deemed an impediment to fair competition. “If Apple believed this court would tolerate such defiance, it was gravely mistaken. The attempt to conceal everything only exacerbates the situation, as always. It will not get a second bite of the apple,” reads a portion of the strongly worded 80-page ruling.
Crucially, the investigation revealed that Apple not only acted contrary to the previous order but did so deliberately and knowingly. Apple’s Vice President of Finance, Alex Roman, even allegedly lied under oath. As a result, the judge has referred the matter to state prosecutors, raising the specter of a business dispute transforming into a criminal investigation.
Apple representatives have stated that they will comply with this new ruling, which currently applies to the United States. However, they also intend to appeal. Nevertheless, this represents a significant defeat for Apple and a major triumph for Epic Games – and for gamers. “We are offering a peace agreement,” announced Epic CEO Tim Sweeney following the verdict. “If Apple implements the court-ordered, no-fee setup globally, we will return Fortnite to the App Store worldwide and cease all current lawsuits.”